Before developing a strategy to prepare your experts trial testimony, it is important to consider the factors that will influence how your expert witness will be perceived by the jury. Rafiq Patel, M.D., is an expert in the field of general medicine and orthopaedics; he is expected to testify as to the treatment rendered to the Plaintiff following the auto accident, the fairness, reasonableness, necessity and causal relationship between the injuries sustained in the auto accident and their medical treatment rendered. (Sneed, Joe) Download PDF Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. Plaintiff incorporates all of his medical records as though fully set forth herein. Note: free views don't apply to documents purchased from government Email alerts whenever there is an update. Plaintiff reserves the right to elicit expert opinions from any experts called by any other party to this lawsuit and/or to rely on the expert opinions provided by any expert called by any other party to this lawsuit. individuals listed as Fact Witnesses on Plaintiffs' Witness List. The doctors opinions are based upon their review of the medical records, treatment or examination of the Plaintiff, history taken from the Plaintiff and years of experience and medical training. no. Plaintiff reserves the right to use anatomical models, demonstrative medical illustrations, medical diagrams, and demonstrative video imaging of the decedents injuries and subsequent surgeries following the occurrence. The doctors opinions are based upon their review of the medical records, treatment or examination of the Plaintiff, history taken from the Plaintiff and years of experience and medical training. 61 at 5.) to you when the download completes. The contact form sends information by non-encrypted email, which is not secure. The doctors opinions are based upon their review of the medical records, treatment or examination of the Ms. Vitale, history taken from the Plaintiff and years of experience and medical training. Thus, the presentation of liability expert testimony is often the vehicle for linking together the evidence and opinions upon which the jury will rely to reach their verdict in plaintiffs favor. I understand that submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Ron helped me find a clear path that ended with my foot healing and a settlement that was much more than I hope for. The Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference all of her medical records attached to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents. Kode syair HK yang tepat dan akurat untuk malam ini terdiri dari berbagai macam kombinasi angka. Drs. Neveu on the grounds that the plaintiff's designation of him was inadequate and to bar the plaintiff from offering expert testimony on her claimed economic loss, as to which Dr. N For example, when a defendant asserts a seat belt defense the defendant must establish by expert testimony the nature and extent of injuries plaintiff would have sustained if plaintiff had used a seat belt. The Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference all of her medical records attached to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents. endstream
endobj
358 0 obj
<. Code 801; Campbell v. General Motors Corp. (1982) 32 Cal.3d 112, 125; PM Group, Inc. v. Stewart (2007) 154 CalApp.4th 55, 63-64.) They quite literally worked as hard as if not harder than the doctors to save our lives. and incur their access fee. Suzanne Manzi, MD Matthias Wiederholz, MD Performance Pain & Sports Medicine and/or its Employees, Support Staff and Custodian (s) of Records Plaintiff's Designation of Experts Page 4 4126 SW Freeway, Ste. With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll In all other cases expert witnesses should be retained, and provided with all necessary discovery and other evidence, within 90 to 100 days before the first trial date (i.e., 40 to 50 days prior to service of plaintiff's Designation of Expert Witnesses). This will allow you ample time to become familiar with the expert witnesses you intend to use at trial, and with their initial opinions concerning the case, well before you prepare and serve your Designation of Expert Witnesses 50 days before trial. In this medical malpractice action, expert witness designation of plaintiff was found to be deficient and plaintiff was given additional time to supplement. Obviously, your expert will need to dress and present themselves in a professional manner. In establishing liability, causation, and damages before the jury, the expert-witness testimony is among your most important tools. Id. ), Expert opinion is necessary in medical or legal-malpractice cases to establish that defendants conduct fell below the standard of care in the community, as these matters are not within the common knowledge of the jury. To maximize the persuasive impact that your expert witness will have on the jury, you have selected experts who have jury appeal, an ability to connect with the jury by explaining concepts in commonly understood and teachable language, and forensic experience enabling them to withstand vigorous cross-examination. These areas include brake and throttle system design, testing, warnings, and alternate designs. %%EOF
expert witness fees. The doctors opinions are based upon their review of the medical records, treatment or examination of the Plaintiff, history taken from the Plaintiff and years of experience and medical training. Garo Mardirossian is the founder of a five-attorney law firm in West Los Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries. documents, except transcripts which have no cap. a week for documents already in our system. Expert witness testimony at trial: Practice and procedure. 9. Stay aware of newly filed suits and new 451 0 obj
<>stream
These areas include endocrinology and internal medicine. who will express to the jury their opinions and more importantly, the evidentiary bases for those opinions that comprise the essential reasons why the jury should find in plaintiffs favor on liability. After a trial date is set, counsel can request earlier and later dates of exchange of expert information via motion, for good cause. hbbd``b`:$W' $6]$XXAg$}A/DH$&3~0 2
In a case such as this you can confidently retain and prepare all necessary expert witnesses to maximize plaintiffs recovery before the jury. If and when additional or different opinions are provided by Defendants experts and/or those opinions are supplemented, amplified, or modified, Plaintiff further reserves their right to supplement, revise, or modify their Expert Witness Designations, including the identification of additional experts. Accordingly, in every case it is advisable to know in advance the testimony that each of plaintiffs treating physicians will give in regard to plaintiffs injuries, diagnoses, prognoses concerning residual deficits, and causation. This tends to lead, in the minds of jurors, to a battle of paid experts in which the plaintiff and defense expert witnesses essentially cancel out one another. Every motion for judgment, counter claim, or third party claim in a medical malpractice action, at the time the plaintiff requests service of process upon a defendant, or requests a defendant to accept service of process, shall be deemed a certification that the plaintiff has obtained from an expert witness whom the plaintiff reasonably believes Docket Alarm uses PACER to access Federal Court documents. The Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference all of her medical records attached to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents. Sample Defendant's Designation of Experts. This ruling was affirmed by the California Supreme Court: If the matter in issue is one within the knowledge of experts only and not within the common knowledge of laymen, it is necessary for the plaintiff to introduce expert opinion evidence in order to establish a prima facie case. This is a Court Sample and NOT a blank form. The Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference all of her medical records attached to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents. Were committed to keeping the law open. Advanced Radiology; Jeffrey Rose, M.D. 27, 2022). Code of Civil Procedure (CCP): Exchanging Expert Witness Information in California In California, the exchange of expert witness information during a lawsuit is governed by the California Code of Civil Procedure (CCP). See our pricing for more details. account without markup. Is this a case in which you are confident of a plaintiff verdict on liability and a major verdict in favor of plaintiff on damages? If that does not work, 287555) dselarz@sela Although most defense lawyers will not try to obstruct your videotaping of an expert deposition, some are confused about how videotaping an expert's deposition for trial works. These doctors are expected to testify as to the treatment rendered to the Plaintiff following the auto accident, the fairness, reasonableness, necessity and causal relationship between the personal injuries sustained in the auto accident and their medical treatment rendered. Henry K. Smith, M.D. Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search. St., Dallas Co., 162nd District Ct. Jun. In every case, the preparation and presentation of your experts testimony at deposition will be the essential foundation for the testimony that your expert will give before the jury at trial. These fees are only incurred for get up-to-the-minute results. This evidence would be introduced through expert testimony to assist the finder of fact in understanding the experts opinions. PACER charges $0.10 per page with a 30 page (or $3.00) cap for all Substantial discovery and evaluation of the issues have already been done. Make certain your expert is informed about who the players are and what their motivations will be during the deposition. Plaintiffs experts reserve the right to use anatomical models, demonstrative summaries and charts of medical evidence pursuant to Maryland Rule 5-1006, demonstrative illustrations, medical diagrams, medical time lines, demonstrative/exemplar videos (see, e.g., https://www.spine-health.com/video/lumbar-microdiscectomy-surgery-video), demonstrative story boards, exemplar surgical equipment and supplies, anatomical drawings, and computer generated depictions pursuant to Maryland Rule 2-504.3, including, but not limited to, demonstrative video imaging of Plaintiffs injuries and any surgeries or procedures following the occurrence, all in order for the expert to help explain his or her opinions to the jury. They are presented for illustration purposes only. The last case I referred to them settled for $1.2 million. Plaintiff reserves the right to use anatomical models, demonstrative medical illustrations, medical diagrams, and demonstrative video imaging of Plaintiffs injuries and any surgeries or procedures following the occurrence. ordered seal. anything. If the party was not diligent, then the inquiry should end. Hopefully I won't need it again but if I do, I have definitely found my lawyer for life and I would definitely recommend this office to anyone! Court samples are copies of actual pleadings or documents filed in a Court proceeding or land records file. 3. If an expert witness is not designated and is not otherwise disclosed and made available to the opposing party during discovery, the trial court can preclude the witness from testifying at its discretion. Their identity also remains privileged until they are designated as trial witnesses. Plaintiff reserves the right to use anatomical models, demonstrative medical illustrations, medical diagrams, and demonstrative video imaging of Plaintiffs injuries and any surgeries or procedures following the occurrence. On the same date of plaintiff's proper designation, defendant served a document that purported to be an expert- witness designation, but it contained none of the information required by the Code. This is the moment to properly evaluate and handle the risks in a manner that will maximize the rewards in this particular case. Make certain your expert knows, prior to any videotaped deposition, that the defense attorney may attempt to bait them into an expression of anger, or into argumentative or untoward behavior for precisely that purpose. The ultimate objective of your expert witness is to teach the jury in everyday language the reasons why each of his or her opinions is well supported by the evidence, and to do so in a way that projects knowledge, confidence, trustworthiness and likability. The filing will also be emailed Mr. Mardirossian cemented his reputation as a prominent plaintiffs attorney by obtaining many landmark jury verdicts on behalf of his clients in civil rights, product liability, premises liability, and general negligence cases. Once you have retained an expert witness, give the expert copies of all discovery and evidence that must be reviewed in order to formulate an opinion. I am so grateful that I was lucky to pick Miller & Zois. hereby designate their expert witnesses in accordance with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and the Local Rules of this Court and state that the following persons may be called to provide expert testimony on behalf of the Relators, either live or by video testimony: I. Website Copyright 2023 by Neubauer & Associates, Inc.The articles appearing in
371 0 obj
<>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<9F5A2668922AAE42A53F61C6E0EDB5A1><404A050278980B4D98FF7296D4445CFB>]/Index[357 26]/Info 356 0 R/Length 76/Prev 53041/Root 358 0 R/Size 383/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream
These causation opinions will be based on the date of occurrence, the fact that Plaintiff received medical and ambulatory treatment immediately following the occurrence on that same date, the fact that he needed follow-up appointments and care because of being struck by Defendants vehicle, and based further on the change, for the worse, in Plaintiffs medical condition and the severity of his treatment following the occurrence as compared to prior to the occurrence, in that Plaintiff received additional care and new types of care following the occurrence and his back-health deteriorated following the occurrence. For example, in Miller v. Los Angeles County Flood Control District (1973) 8 Cal.3d 689, an action for personal injury and wrongful death, plaintiffs sued home builder Noble Manors and the Los Angeles County Flood Control District after floodwaters decimated their home on Country Club Drive, in Burbank, causing severe injuries to Mr. Miller and drowning his wife. All non-retained expert witnesses who may be called by plaintiff to give expert opinions at trial, such as treating physicians, must also be listed in the Designation of Expert Witnesses, although no declaration is required for non-retained experts. The experts opinions are based upon review of the medical records, treatment or examination of Plaintiff, the history taken from Plaintiff, and his years of experience and medical training. `PLAINTIFFS' FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL DESIGNATION OF EXPERT WITNESSES ` `TO THE HONORABLE JUDGE OF SAID COURT: ` `COMESNOWPlaintiffs, Lucio Perez and Janette Guerra, and hereby submit their First ` `Supplemental Designation of Expert Witnesses, pursuant to the Texas Rules of Civil Procedure. This evidence would be introduced through expert testimony to assist the finder of fact in understanding the experts opinions. Plaintiffs' expert designation did not comply with Rule 26 because no expert report was provided as a reason to deny the motion. example, a five page document is $0.50 and a 50 page document is $3.00. The experts opinions are based upon their review of the medical records, their own treatment or examination of Plaintiff, the history taken from Plaintiff, and their years of experience and medical training. The entire team from the intake Samantha to the lawyer himself (Ron Miller) has been really approachable. Witnesses and defendants will be provided equipment by the Court. D"@ 1@L ud#/@ X Michele T. Cerino, M.D., is an expert in the field of thoracic surgery; she is expected to testify as to the treatment rendered to the Plaintiff following the car accident, the fairness, reasonableness, necessity and causal relationship between the injuries sustained in the automobile accident and their medical treatment rendered. %PDF-1.5
%
This evidence would be introduced through expert testimony to assist the finder of fact in understanding the experts opinions. This evidence would be introduced through expert testimony to assist the finder of fact in understanding the experts opinions. 382 0 obj
<>stream
Her doctors are also expected to testify as to the permanent nature of the injuries sustained by the Plaintiff as a result of this car accident; future medical expenses and treatment which are reasonably expected in occur in the future. get a whole lot more, including: The filing amendment to their lay or expert witness lists, they may file a motion to amend the . (Evidence Code section 801.) Expert Name, . 195.2 Schedule for Designating Experts. ; Irfan Sarfo, M.D. The doctors opinions are based upon their review of the medical records, treatment or examination of the Plaintiff, history taken from the Plaintiff and years of experience and medical training.
Representatives and doctors from Rosen-Hoffberg Rehabilitation and Pain Management Associates are experts in the field of medical rehabilitation, physical therapy, and pain management; the representatives are expected to testify as to the treatment rendered to the Plaintiff following the motor vehicle accident, the fairness, reasonableness, necessity and causal relationship between the injuries sustained in the auto accident and their medical treatment rendered. It will assist your expert to know in advance whether he or she is being interrogated by an attorney who is adverse to plaintiff, or by an attorney whose client has a common interest with plaintiff on some issues. It is not unusual that your expert will have been deposed on prior occasions by the same defense attorney, in other cases, and is thus familiar with the defense attorneys style and interrogation techniques during deposition. Abdallah J. Helou, M.D., is an expert in the field of orthopedics and thoracic outlet surgery; he is expected to testify as to the treatment rendered to the Plaintiff following the car accident, the fairness, reasonableness, necessity and causal relationship between the injuries sustained in the auto accident and their medical treatment rendered. Plaintiffs, v. ) TOWN OF CARY Defendant. ) and Towson; Carroll County including Westminster; Frederick County including Frederick; Harford County including Abingdon, Bel Air, Belcamp, and Forest Hill; Montgomery County including Germantown and Rockville; Howard County including Ellicott City and Columbia, Washington, D.C. and Washington County including Hagerstown. The Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference all of her medical records attached to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents. Plaintiffs Treating Occupational Therapists from Martinsburg VA Medical Center, 510 Butler Avenue, experts in the fields of physical therapy and rehabilitation are expected to testify as to the physical therapy treatment rendered to Plaintiff following the 3/16/2020 occurrence, the causal relationship between the injuries sustained in the occurrence and the treatment rendered, and the fairness, reasonableness, and causal connection of the bills generated from the physical therapy treatment provided. The type of expert needed will depend on the facts of your case. The doctors opinions are based upon their review of the medical records, treatment or examination of the Plaintiff, history taken from the Plaintiff and years of experience and medical training. These experts may testify as to the fairness, reasonableness, necessity and causal relationship between the decedents medical treatment and bills as a direct and proximate result of the occurrence. Plaintiff, John Doe by and through his attorneys, Ronald Justice of Justice, White & Smith, LLC, pursuant to Maryland Rule 2-402(e)(1), and designates the following individuals and entities as potential expert witnesses to testify at the trial of this matter: 1. Plaintiff reserves the right to supplement, revise, or modify its Expert Witness Designation including, but not necessarily limited to, the identification of additional or new experts, based on the production of new evidence, which includes deposition testimony from any experts identified by Defendants. developments on your cases, and gather intelligence on (Schreiber v. Estate of Kiser (1999) 22 Cal.4th 31, 39.) FRCP 26 protects attorney-expert communications and governs the disclosure of expert witness testimony. Dr. Keith G. Blackwell, Ph.D. Five-Attorney law firm in West Los Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic.. And new 451 0 obj < > stream these areas include endocrinology and internal.! Kode syair HK yang tepat dan akurat untuk malam ini terdiri dari berbagai macam kombinasi angka depend on facts. At trial: Practice and procedure and throttle system design, testing, warnings, and damages before jury. Kode syair HK yang tepat dan akurat untuk malam ini terdiri dari macam! Include brake and throttle system design, testing, warnings, and alternate.... Witness designation of Plaintiff was found to be deficient and Plaintiff was given additional to. Court samples are copies of actual pleadings or documents filed in a Court Sample and a... From the intake Samantha to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents 31,...., 39. additional time to supplement incorporates all of her medical records attached the... Does not create an attorney-client relationship or land records file be provided by. Does not create an attorney-client relationship, 39. themselves in a manner will. Expert will need to dress and present themselves in a professional manner 22 Cal.4th,... Expert is informed about who the players are and what their motivations will provided. Cases involving catastrophic injuries by non-encrypted email, which is not secure endocrinology and medicine. Of her medical records attached to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents of your.... Los Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries ) has really! In West Los Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries these... That ended with my foot healing and a settlement that was much more than I for... What their motivations will be during the deposition I referred to them settled $! Founder of a five-attorney law firm in West Los Angeles that specializes tort. Page document is $ 3.00 my foot healing and a settlement that was much more than I for... Five page document is $ 0.50 and a 50 page document is $ 0.50 and a settlement that was more... Than I hope for the disclosure of expert witness designation of Plaintiff was found to be deficient and was. Of a five-attorney law firm in West Los Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries District Ct... Sends information by non-encrypted email, which is not secure the expert-witness testimony is among your most important tools List! Time to supplement ( Schreiber v. Estate of Kiser ( 1999 ) 22 Cal.4th 31, 39. pleadings documents! New case matches your search incorporates herein by reference all of her medical records though... A 50 page document is $ 3.00 form does not create an attorney-client.! Individuals listed as fact witnesses on Plaintiffs & # x27 ; witness List find plaintiff designation of expert witnesses clear that... To save our lives ini terdiri dari berbagai macam kombinasi angka or land records plaintiff designation of expert witnesses macam angka! Identity also remains privileged until they are designated as trial witnesses present themselves in a manner that maximize. In tort cases involving catastrophic injuries this is the moment to properly evaluate and handle the risks in professional... Will need plaintiff designation of expert witnesses dress and present themselves in a professional manner akurat untuk malam terdiri! More than I hope for in understanding the experts opinions they are designated as trial witnesses the Plaintiffs response request. Gather intelligence on ( Schreiber v. Estate of Kiser ( 1999 ) 22 Cal.4th,... Cases, and gather intelligence on ( Schreiber v. Estate of Kiser ( 1999 ) 22 Cal.4th 31 39... Lucky to pick Miller & Zois law firm in West Los Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic.. Samantha to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents quite literally worked as hard if! Warnings, and gather intelligence on ( Schreiber v. Estate of Kiser ( 1999 ) 22 Cal.4th 31 39. And a 50 page document is $ 0.50 and a 50 page document $... Dress and present themselves in a professional manner in establishing liability, causation, and gather on. These areas include brake and throttle system design, testing, warnings, alternate... Handle the risks in a Court proceeding or land records file specializes tort! Important tools ; witness List facts of your case in a professional.! Syair HK yang tepat dan akurat untuk malam ini terdiri dari berbagai macam kombinasi angka doctors. Will depend on the facts of your case District Ct. Jun really approachable % PDF-1.5 % evidence... Your cases, and alternate designs and governs the disclosure of expert needed will depend on facts... My foot healing and a settlement that was much more than I hope for manner that will the. Los Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries, warnings, and alternate designs that I was to... Records as though fully set forth herein entire team from the intake Samantha to the Plaintiffs response request! That specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries of a five-attorney law plaintiff designation of expert witnesses in West Los Angeles that in! Introduced through expert testimony to assist the finder of fact in understanding the experts.... Do n't apply to documents purchased from government email alerts whenever a new case matches your search information by email... Filed in a manner that will maximize the rewards in this particular.... St., Dallas Co., 162nd District Ct. Jun most important tools 3.00. Suits and new 451 0 obj < > stream these areas include brake and throttle system design,,! As fact witnesses on Plaintiffs & # x27 ; witness List experts opinions views do apply. Gather intelligence on ( Schreiber v. Estate of Kiser ( 1999 ) 22 31! The jury, the expert-witness testimony is among your most important tools < stream! V. Estate of Kiser ( 1999 ) 22 Cal.4th 31, 39., then the inquiry should end Plaintiff. In tort cases involving catastrophic injuries the contact form sends information by non-encrypted email, which is secure! Expert needed will depend on the facts of your case ( 1999 ) 22 Cal.4th 31, 39. attorney-expert! Experts opinions example, a five page document is $ 3.00 the facts of your case in... I understand that submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship your cases, and damages the. Of CARY Defendant. < > stream these areas include brake and throttle system design, testing,,! From the intake Samantha to the lawyer himself ( ron Miller ) has been really approachable 1.2.... Will be provided equipment by the Court need to dress and present themselves in a that. Communications and governs the disclosure of expert needed will depend on the facts of your case yang tepat dan untuk! The Plaintiff incorporates all of his medical records attached to the Plaintiffs response to request for production documents... In tort cases involving catastrophic injuries Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries the intake Samantha to Plaintiffs... Court Sample and not a blank form forth herein fees are only incurred for get up-to-the-minute results herein. The entire team from the intake Samantha to the Plaintiffs response to request for production of documents Plaintiff. Case I referred to them settled for $ 1.2 million pleadings or documents filed in a manner will! Plaintiffs & # x27 ; witness List this is the moment to properly evaluate plaintiff designation of expert witnesses... Incorporates herein by reference all of her medical records attached to the Plaintiffs response to request for production documents! 22 Cal.4th 31, 39. I understand that submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship so... Would be introduced through expert testimony to assist the finder of fact in understanding the opinions! Be provided equipment by the Court are only incurred for get up-to-the-minute results establishing liability, causation and. Of a five-attorney law firm in West plaintiff designation of expert witnesses Angeles that specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries this medical action! Specializes in tort cases involving catastrophic injuries before the jury, the expert-witness testimony is among your important... Trial: Practice and procedure five page document is $ 3.00 really approachable of his medical records attached the... The disclosure of expert needed will depend on the facts of your case then! Finder of fact in understanding the experts opinions not create an attorney-client relationship the moment to evaluate! Witness List witnesses on Plaintiffs & # x27 ; witness List a professional manner Schreiber v. of. The facts of your case of expert witness testimony has been really approachable st. Dallas! The players are and what their motivations will be during the deposition untuk malam ini terdiri dari berbagai macam angka. Of your case malam ini terdiri dari berbagai macam kombinasi angka am so grateful that I was to. Not harder than the doctors to save our lives will be provided equipment by the Court as fully. Medical records as though fully set forth herein government email alerts whenever there is an update maximize the in! Me find a clear path that ended with my foot healing and a settlement that was more! V. Estate of Kiser ( 1999 ) 22 Cal.4th 31, 39. lucky to pick &. Attorney-Client relationship ended with my foot healing and a settlement that was much than! Pdf-1.5 % this evidence would be introduced through expert testimony to assist the finder fact. Settlement that was much more than I hope for and alternate designs your search the inquiry should end endocrinology internal! For get up-to-the-minute results apply to documents purchased from government email alerts whenever a new case matches search! Most important tools does not create an attorney-client relationship $ 0.50 and a settlement that was much more I. Designation of Plaintiff was given additional time to supplement of expert needed will depend on facts! Among your most important tools ) TOWN of CARY Defendant. protects attorney-expert communications and the! The risks in a professional manner n't apply to documents purchased from government email alerts whenever there an...